Fan poll: Grading Georgia's season

semerson@macon.comJanuary 3, 2013 

Georgia's win in its bowl, and Florida's loss, likely ensures that the Bulldogs will finish the season ranked in the top 5 nationally. But how do the team's own fans view this season? I went to Twitter to find out.

The question was simple: Grade the Bulldogs' season (A+, A, A-, B+, and so on.) And then say why.

Here are the responses, grouped by grades, and scroll to the end to see what the team's official GPA ended up being:


Twelve wins, beat Florida, won our New Year's bowl game and came up 4 yards short of the NC game. Keep some perspective - Clay Waterfill, @clayfill

An "A" because 12 wins is 12 wins. Five yards from an A+. - Mike Youmans, @MrYoumans

Won 12 games. Only a few others can do that this season Bc it's hard to do. Beat all 4 main rivals. Won East. 1 BAD loss. - DawgsOnTop, @mckelley19

They were 5 yards from playing in the big game. 5 yards from an A+. I don't care about the loss to USC. - Steve Chalk, @sjchalk

Five yards from A+. Only the third time in Uga history there is a 12 in the win column. Nothing short of an A worthy - Rob McRae, @rbmcrae

Solid A!! 5 yards from BCS champ game. Only issue was Scar! - Go Dawgs, @cmilies2005

Offense a pleasure to watch. Defense frustrating at times, but this team played with a lead much of the season. - Homeboy Upstairs, @homeboyupstairs

"A", as I think "A+" is only set up for perfection. We got close but no exactly perfect. Yet a FANTASTIC run & great team!!!!!! - Andy M. Johnson, @GeorgiaGunOwner

My only legit complaint is losing to South Carolina in consecutive years. Gave Tide all they could handle. Won bowl. - A Rosenberg, @ARosenberg17

Would be an A+ if they Would have got 7 more yards against Bama on that last drive... - Kyle Szigeti, @CPA_dawg

Four points away from an A+, but still one of the best all-around teams in UGA history. 12 wins, huge records, PASSION. - Ray Baker, @Ray_Baker7

Five yards away from an A+ - Clint Patrick, @clintpat3

Took care of business in all but one game. Got better throughout season. - Joey Jones, @joeyjones3


A+ would have been a national title showing, and an A would have been a SEC title. 12 wins and national respect gets an A-. - Grant Wood, @GrantWoodGA

Laid a great big egg against SC, but finished super strong w/ impressive development on O. Lots to be excited about in '13. - Laura Garrett, @lmgarrett11

We won SEC east. Conference win or not losing to SC would have got an A. Great season though. - Mark Meeks, @mmeeks00

A- would be about right. - Brandon Harper, @BrandonHarper30

Twelve wins and an SEC East championship gets you an "A" but dawgs best win was against that Florida team we saw last night. - Drain, @shane_the_drain

A play away from SECC & Natty shot. But marks off for 1. Not showing up AT ALL vs. SC & 2. Squandering so much talent on D. - TNRLM, @TNRLM

Great year, but D was inconsistent and underperformed; offense was a huge bright spot. - Not Alan, @notalanm

Hard to argue with 12 wins, 1 of best offenses in NCAA; Defense inconsistent/underperformed with multitude of star players. - BEvans, @brantdevans

Pluses: 4 yards from National Championship game, 12 wins; Minuses: Run defense, not showing up for So. Carolina game. - Virgil Cole, @vcolejr

I give overall team A-. Loss to South Carolina was bad. Mike Bobo an A+, Richt an A. Grantham B-. Overcame lots of adversity - Hobnail Boot Blog, @hobnailbootblog

They were gashed on D at times, but you can't bash a 12 win team in the SEC too much. - JP Ott, @jonpaulott

The USC game keeps it from being a solid A. Great season otherwise. - Eric Johnson, @ericleif

Can't get anything less because we got 12 wins but we were embarrassed by USC and came short of our goals. Good year though. - Andrew Holbrook, @aholbrook0523

SEC east championship, wins over UF, UT, Aub, and GT. solid coaching and only 5 yards from a national title shot. - Eric Streitenberger, @estreit4

Great season. The minus is for defense performing short of expectations and performance against the run. - Russ Butcher, @russbutcher

Didn't show up for the SC game but recovered nicely and were 5 yards from Miami and the BCS 'ship. Good bowl win to wrap up - Lucas Puente, @lucaspuente

Twelve wins, bowl win,Florida win, SEC East title . Minus for South Carolina loss & mistakes, softness pre-Shawn Williams tirade. - Robert K. Burnham, @robertkburnham

We also beat most of our rivals and came just short of a national champ bid and an SEC championship. - Andrew Holbrook, @aholbrook0523

Twelve win season, but fell short in Columbia and Atlanta. 12 wins is nothing to be ashamed of but fell short of our goal again. - Alex Crawford, @Alexcrawford12

You only get an A for winning SEC. A+ would be a natty. 12 win seasons don't happen very often. 5 yards and it would be A+. - Drew, @drewgodawgs32

Twelve wins and beat Florida - Dan, @atldan

Housed by SC, uneven yr for D; but, O showed out, D tightenedup when necc,12 wins,bowl V 5 yds from NC. A feel good season. - BJL, @_BJL_

I would give the 2012 Dawgs an A-. Beat FLA, AU, UT and tech but bad loss to Spurrier and 5 yards from glory. - GATA Dawgs, @BassinDawg

Won East, finished in top 5, beat UF, GT, Aub, & Tenn, won bowl. Win SEC for A. Win BCS for A+. - Trey, @cpadawg

Overall a good/great season. A ding for an underachieving defense. Stop the run better -> probable NC birth. - J.D., @jdmyers

A-. - Danny Marshall, @tdannymarshall

A-. - Scott Seckinger, @msseck

A- for me. Quick ? for you, it seemed like Branden Smith was invisible this year. Is that b/c no teams were throwing his way? - Bert Brantley, @bertbrantley

Quick response: Smith didn't play as much, supplanted early by Damian Swann for the second spot.


They had A+ talent but fell short on 2/3 of their biggest stages. - Ben Ralston, @ben_ralston

Lost of #82 and #15 hurt some. D underachieved at times. Would be an A if not for the egg we laid in Columbia. - Joe Moore10, @joemoore10

Great year...but to get an A you have to win the SEC....and to get an have to win the whole thing! A- would be undftd reg season, A would be SEC Champs, A+ would be National Champs. - Tgentry97, @tgentry97

Offense was great. Run defense horrible. To many 2nd half adjustments that should’ve been caught before game started. - Clarke, @SeeLarkeRun

Made it to SEC Championship, but couldn't pull out a victory. Beat Florida. Will finish in the Top 5. - J.J. Collins, @JJ_Danger

Ultimately fell short of the biggest goal which was winning the SEC Championship. - Clint Thomason, @ClintThomason

Given expectations, it's hard to not be disappointed with the defense. Had the USC game turned out differently, maybe an A. - Bruce Baker, @BruceBakerATL

After the loss to SC they didn't let the season fall apart. Then the way they played Bama in the SEC championship game. - Vinson Pope, @vtpope

Offense was outstanding-12 wins-beat UF-Defense average shoulda been elite-embarrassed by S.C.-Coulda made Miami and didn't - RealityCheck, @Blocked4Facts

Can't be an A without winning Sec and getting embarrassed by Carolina, but I do think Richt got some of his swag back. - Bryan Hall, @cattledawgs

Best possible grade for a season that includes no championships and no BCS appearance. - VineyardDawg, @vineyarddawg

Great season (minus Columbia) but no championship and championships SHOULD BE the measuring stick at Georgia. - James Hughes, @@JimmyHughes416

Offense overachieved but D underachieved. Both sides rarely played well at the same time. Above average season overall. - El Tigre Law, @ElTigreLaw

Team expected to compete for MNC 5 yards away; that's good. Record-setting O. No A b/c of up/down slow-start D. I had fun. - Danny Polinsky, @dannypolinsky

Give it a B+. Given all the returners on defense, they should have been dominant all season long. Still, 12 wins is impressive. - Phil Lashley, @phlashley

Twelve wins is not easy but went 2 - 2 in biggest games. - Andy Burns, @asburns1973

Twelve wins, beat Fla, great Bama game but looked bad at SC, bad at run D, spike ball. - J. Lance Bray, @lancerbray

Won the east not the #sec . Offense was great but D under achieved. A for winning #SEC . A+ for getting a BCS title shot. - Brandon, @lowaryb

Anytime you get destroyed in a game like against SC you can't get an A. 12 Wins and SEC East title = successful year! - UGA FANternity, @UGAFanternity


Solid B. Defense underperformed all year, but made plays when they had to. Offense disappeared when it mattered. - Corey Gast, @CoreyGast

Solid B for offensive improvements. Problems stopping the run & SC loss keep from being an A. Murray needs consistency. - Isom Steve Phillips, @IsomPhillips


I give UGA a B-. Would be higher except for SCAR debacle. Without that game, A-. - Dawggirl, @MelissaRabb1

- B-. - Brandt joel, @jbrandtjoal


Final GPA:


Thanks to my lovely wife, a UGA professor, for computing this. She calls it a "very good grade."

Follow Seth Emerson at @sethemerson.

Ledger-Enquirer is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service