A jury now decides whether Dana Kessler and Timothy Robinson go to prison for the April 6, 2012, fatal shooting of Jeffrey Morgan during a drug deal at Columbus Sands Apartments, 1213 Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd.
Jurors must determine whether Kessler intentionally or accidentally fired the .45-caliber bullet that went through Morgans right arm and into his chest, severing an aorta so Morgan bled to death internally.
They must ponder whether Kessler planned to rob Morgan, or whether as he claims, he was trying to sell Morgan the gun when it fired accidentally.
They must consider his attorneys claims that Kessler would not have confessed to robbing and shooting Morgan had he not been drunk and on prescription drugs the night detectives questioned him for four hours.
And they must decide whether Robinsons role warrants his being convicted as an accomplice in a robbery and homicide, or whether he only set up a deal so Kessler could buy marijuana, not rob and shoot the dealer.
According to Assistant District Attorney Sadhana Dailey, the proof Robinson and Kessler conspired to rob Morgan is evidenced by what they did immediately afterward:
They left in two separate cars Robinson driving Kesslers car and Kessler driving Morgans and used Talley Avenue for a rendezvous where they left Morgans car after they got 2 or 3 ounces of marijuana from it. Then they fled in Kesslers vehicle.
Dailey noted an eyewitness who saw the fatal shot fired testified he ran across the boulevard, looked back and saw Robinson and another suspect leave the apartments parking lot in Kesslers gray Mitsubishi. Then he saw Kessler drag Morgan from the drivers seat of Morgans blue Mazda and speed away in it, he said.
How does Kessler, driving the victims car, know to go to Talley Avenue? asked Dailey -- unless they planned it that way.
Kesslers lawyer, Chief Public Defender Moffett Flournoy, said his client would not have planned to kill Morgan that way because he would not have planned to shoot someone with so loud a gun in the middle of the afternoon, in a public place, with a witness present.
This has to be the dumbest way to commit a murder, if thats what youre intending to do, Flournoy said.
According to court testimony, Robinson by cell phone set up the meeting between Kessler and Morgan in the apartments parking lot.
When Robinson and Kessler arrived in Kesslers Mitsubishi around 2:30 p.m., Morgan already was dealing with another customer, Shatoric Hinton, who was sitting in the front passenger seat of Morgans Mazda.
Robinson got in the back seat behind Morgan; Kessler got in behind Hinton. A third suspect, Edward Love, stayed in Kesslers car.
According to Hinton, Morgan handed a bag of marijuana to Robinson, who gave it to Kessler and said it was the same theyd had before. Kessler put the bag in a cup holder and pulled out the handgun, pointing it between the front seats at Morgan, who upon seeing the weapon begged Kessler not to shoot, Hinton said.
Then the gun went off. Hinton got out and ran. Robinson ran to Kesslers car. Kessler got out of Morgans back seat, opened the drivers door and told Morgan to get out. I cant! Kessler told police Morgan screamed.
So Kessler pulled Morgan out, threw him to the ground and left in Morgans car, running over Morgan as he sped away, Hinton testified.
Kessler testified he was trying to help Morgan out of the car, but Morgan collapsed. Kessler said he then saw Morgans car moving and realized Love was leaving in it as Robinson started to leave in Kesslers car. So Kessler ran to his Mitsubishi and got in the back seat, and then Robinson and Love drove the cars to Talley Avenue, Kessler said.
Robinsons attorney, Stacey Jackson, has maintained his client did nothing more than set up a marijuana deal, and was merely a witness to the robbery and shooting that ensued. He had no gun and no marijuana.
As evidence Robinson was just a bystander, Jackson pointed to Kesslers testimony that Robinson got out of Morgans Mazda and closed the door before the gun fired.
Dailey countered that Robinson was crucial to the whole set-up: Kessler could not have done this without Timothy Robinson. She noted Kessler in 2009 had moved here from New York, knew few local residents and only a few ways around town. He was dependent on Robinsons guidance that Good Friday 2012, the day Morgan died.
She replayed video recordings of Kesslers interview with police. It was supposed to be a robbery-type thing, Kessler told detectives. Calling the gun the thing, he told them Robinson had advised him Morgan would be unarmed and surrender whatever drugs or cash he had, as soon as Kessler put the thing up.
Thats what I did. I put the thing up," Kessler added.
Referring to Robinson as Buddy, Kessler said of Morgan: He gave Buddy the sack of weed. As soon as he gave him the weed, I pulled up the thing. And then, just pop!
Flournoy told jurors they must weigh whether Kesslers statement to police was freely and voluntarily given under the circumstances.
Kessler was questioned from 1:15 a.m. until 5:30 a.m. on April 9, 2012. He had been drinking and appeared half asleep in the recording of his interview, during which police threatened him repeatedly, Flournoy noted.
The video showed investigators also lied, telling Kessler that the other two suspects were in custody and talking to detectives about the shooting, and that nearby security cameras recorded Kessler at the crime scene.
How can you believe a statement that is coerced with lies? Flournoy asked.
One suspect still is not in Columbus police custody: Arrested this past June 12 in Phenix City, Edward Love is being held on charges in Russell County.
Besides murder, Kessler and Robinson face charges of aggravated assault, armed robbery, hijacking a motor vehicle, using a firearm to commit a crime and possessing marijuana.