Casey returns to the stage to sing Kara and Randy's pick: "Daughters" by John Mayer. This is possibly among my top 10 least favorite songs in the universe. Randy thinks Casey has a John Mayer vibe, though.
Wow, this is one of the most boring performances to ever enter the "Idol" stage. Again, Casey sounds fine, I guess. But it's nothing more than fine. You just really can't do much with this song. It does nothing to help Casey earn votes. I think he's on his way out.
Randy: "This fits you like a glove."
Ellen: "I thought that was beautiful for you."
Kara: "This showed the more artistic side of you."
Simon: "It was a bit of a lazy arrangement...That song didn't have that wow factor." Simon is laughing. He's clearly checked out of this season.