Time for welder Matt Breitzke.
He sings Tonic's "If You Could Only See." Actually, it's not too bad. He has a pretty good voice when he really tries, but this song is just boring. It really doesn't do much to build crowd energy or make us want more. Make no mistake: I still kind of have a crush on him. Man, I really wish there wasn't only room for one big working-class guy in the Top 12.
Simon: "I really like you...but I absolutely hated that song."
Randy: "The performance was so boring, it didn't show you to be the great Matt we saw in Hollywood."
Kara: "It didn't show us any side of you."
Paula: "The song did not celebrate who we all fell in love with."