Did viewers find any satisfaction when the top 12 "American Idol" contestants performed Rolling Stones tunes Tuesday night? Well, it wasn't a total train wreck.
Maybe the show wasn't the greatest top 12 night in "Idol" history, but some shaky contestants broke out of their shells.
The most talked-about effort of the night: quirky Siobhan Magnus' take on "Paint It Black." Siobhan took the stage in a gown and combat boots to offer a dramatic rendition of the tune. It included Siobhan's signature big notes, and judge Simon Cowell said he thought she beat front-runner Crystal Bowersox on Tuesday.