He has no experience in elective office. He founded an electric car company that failed to deliver its promise of thousands of vehicles and hundreds of jobs. By his own admission, he relishes making a buck, even if that involves leaving his crying wife and newborn son in a car to attend a fundraiser or making millions on a bankrupt fiber-optics company that left thousands jobless.
Terry McAuliffe should be losing Tuesday’s election for governor of Virginia. Instead, the Democrat is the front-runner in the only competitive gubernatorial race in the nation this year, where a Democratic victory would have national ramifications.
How could that happen? Simple: Voters dislike the other guy more.
McAuliffe’s Republican opponent, Virginia Attorney General and tea party favorite Ken Cuccinelli, is seen as too conservative on issues from abortion to taxes for a rapidly changing state.
Never miss a local story.
“He’s extreme,” said voter Donna Feeney, the chief financial officer for a law firm, who attended a McAuliffe campaign rally this week in the Washington suburb of Herndon.
“He wants to control everything,” said another voter, Mary Jo Ricci, a substitute teacher and self-described independent who’s turned away from Republican candidates in recent years.
In the last nine elections, the party that was holding the White House has lost the Virginia governor’s mansion. But this year, observers say, the race – which is seen as a bellwether for the 2014 and 2016 elections – indicates that Republicans, at least in some states, are headed in the wrong direction.
“This is a microcosm of what’s going on with the party across the country,” said Tom Davis, a moderate Republican who represented Virginia in the House of Representatives for more than a dozen years and supports Cuccinelli. “It may work in Texas and Utah but does not work in purple states and blue states. It’s just simple math.”
Virginia’s recent and dramatic demographic transformation has shifted its electorate from reliably Republican to deeply divided. Thousands of new residents, many of them Latino and Asian immigrants, have crowded the sprawling suburbs outside the nation’s capital, turning the state into a toss-up.
President Barack Obama became the first Democratic presidential candidate to carry the state in more than four decades in 2008, and he won again in 2012. Both U.S. senators are Democrats, but Republicans hold three statewide offices and control the Legislature.
“Virginians really want the practical problem-solver, not the ideologue,” said Sen. Tim Kaine, a Democratic former governor who won a Senate seat last year.
A former state senator who won statewide office four years ago in a landslide, Cuccinelli, 45, is credited with being tea party before there was a tea party. He’s crusaded against Washington and challenged the status quo in Virginia.
He was the first to sue the federal government over the new health care law. He sued the Environmental Protection Agency. He pushed for new restrictions on abortion clinics. He tried to investigate well-known climate scientist Michael Mann, who he said might be engaged in fraud. He told public colleges that they couldn’t pass anti-discrimination policies for gays.
That record might have kept Cuccinelli from the Republican nomination if he’d had to face moderate Republican Lt. Gov. Bill Bolling in a primary. But tea party activists pushed through a change, taking the decision away from statewide Republican voters and giving it to a convention instead, where their organized forces could prevail. Bolling folded.
“Virginia once again has an opportunity. This is an opportunity to show the country that conservatism isn’t dead. . . . That it’s not old or worn out, and that it’s still alive and thriving!” Cuccinelli said last December in a speech to Republicans after it appeared that he’d lock up the nomination.
He’s worked to tar his rival – a former chairman of the national Democratic Party and one of its most prolific fundraisers – as the voice of the Washington establishment and moneyed elites.
“If you like D.C. politics, you’ll love Terry McAuliffe,” he said Monday at a rally with Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky.
McAuliffe, 56, should be a tempting target for Republican criticism. Beyond his record, there’s the fact that he has few ties to the state. He lost a 2009 bid for the Democratic nomination in part because he seemed a carpetbagger.
He’s spent the years since paying his dues at fish fries, neighborhood parties and community college tours. Though he’s still unable to answer some questions about government and glosses over policy details, observers say he managed to overcome the hurdle of inexperience.
“He put to rest concerns that he doesn’t know the state,” said Mark Rozell, a professor at George Mason University.
“Ken Cuccinelli has always focused on issues that divide Virginians,” McAuliffe said Monday at a rally with his close friend, former President Bill Clinton.
The nasty campaign has turned off a lot of voters. At the last debate, Comedy Central’s “The Daily Show” passed out air-sickness bags adorned with the candidates’ faces. As many as 1 in 10 voters are leaning toward the libertarian candidate, Robert Sarvis, as an alternative, with more coming from the Republican column than the Democratic.
But largely the tide is against Cuccinelli.
The reliably conservative newspaper in the state capital, the Richmond Times-Dispatch, declined to endorse anyone for the first time in modern Virginia history, a slap at Cuccinelli.
Will Sessoms, the Republican mayor of Virginia Beach, the state’s largest city, is supporting a Democrat for governor for the first time after Cuccinelli worked against a plan to help ease clogged roads because it included tax increases.
“The days of sitting back and saying we are not going to raise taxes or we are going to reduce taxes are over,” Sessoms said.
Voters are breaking for the Democrat for two main reasons: a strong rejection of Cuccinelli, and strong support from women for McAuliffe.
A whopping 64 percent of those who support McAuliffe are voting against Cuccinelli rather than for McAuliffe, according to a Washington Post/Abt-SRBI poll this week.
Also, while men split almost evenly, women support McAuliffe by double-dight margins, enough to push him ahead by more than 8 points, according to an average compiled by RealClearPolitics.com.
Cuccinelli supporters blame McAuliffe’s millions for a torrent of TV ads that have convinced voters that the attorney general is too extreme by misrepresenting his stance on the issues, some of which they say aren’t pertinent in a state election.
“The negative ads coming out from McAuliffe are libelous,” said Vanice Famme, the president of the Arlington Republican Women’s Club, who attended a Cuccinelli rally this week.
Cuccinelli has tried to appeal to independents and Democrats by speaking about jobs, but he might not have fought back forcefully or quickly enough against allegations that he was an extremist. A number of Republicans, including the former national finance chairman of the Republican National Committee, said they endorsed McAuliffe in part because of Cuccinelli’s “ideological agenda.”
Republican state Sen. Tom Garrett said he was still hopeful that when voters headed to the polls next week they’d realize Cuccinelli was the one with the ideas. “When those voters looks for substance, I think they’re going to drift toward Ken,” he said.